Noah Labhart logoNoah Labhart

Guide

How to hire your first engineers

Hire your first engineers for slope and range rather than for stack familiarity: people who learn fast, work close to customers, and can own a problem end to end. Run a short, consistent loop built around real work, and make the decision on evidence rather than on rapport.

8 min read · Updated 2026-08-06

Who should be your first engineering hire?

A generalist senior engineer who has shipped a product to real users and is comfortable with ambiguity. Specialists are a later-stage optimisation; your first hires will touch infrastructure, backend, frontend and customer conversations in the same week.

  • Range over depth: can they operate two levels outside their comfort zone?
  • Evidence of shipping, not just of building — did users get it?
  • Comfort with unfinished context; startups do not come with specifications.
  • Willingness to talk to customers directly.

What does a good startup interview loop look like?

Four hours total, four stages, the same questions for every candidate, and a written scorecard per stage before anyone discusses the candidate. Consistency is what makes a small loop fair and predictive.

  1. Screen (30 min): motivation, range, comp alignment. Founder or hiring manager.
  2. Technical conversation (60 min): walk through a system they built and interrogate the trade-offs.
  3. Practical exercise (90 min, paid if take-home): a scoped, realistic problem from your actual domain — no algorithm trivia.
  4. Team and values (45 min): how they handle disagreement, feedback and failure.
  5. Debrief within 24 hours; written scorecards submitted before the discussion starts.

How do you assess engineers without a big-company interview process?

Grade for judgment, not recall. The strongest signal at startup scale is watching someone reason through a messy, real problem from your product while you observe how they ask questions.

SignalHow to test itWhat good looks like
JudgmentAsk what they would not build and whyNames the trade-off and the cost of being wrong
OwnershipWalk through a production incident they handledTalks about detection and prevention, not blame
CommunicationHave them explain a system to a non-engineerNo jargon; checks for understanding
Learning speedIntroduce an unfamiliar constraint mid-exerciseAdapts the approach instead of defending it

What should you pay your first engineers?

Pay at or slightly below market cash with meaningful early equity, and be transparent about the trade. Under-paying without equity is how you end up with the candidates nobody else wanted.

Publish bands internally from the first hire. Retrofitting fairness after four ad-hoc offers is far more expensive than starting with a simple, defensible structure.

How do you onboard an engineer so they are productive quickly?

The goal is a merged, deployed change on day one and a meaningful feature by the end of week two. If that is impossible, the onboarding problem is really a tooling problem.

  • One-command local environment, documented and tested by the last person hired.
  • A named buddy for the first 30 days.
  • A starter task that is real, small and shippable.
  • Customer exposure in week one — a support queue day or three recorded calls.

Frequently asked questions

Should a startup hire junior engineers?
Only once there is someone with the time to mentor them and standards encoded in tooling. Juniors are a great investment at 10+ engineers and a serious risk as the first hire.
Are take-home assignments still acceptable?
Yes if they are short, scoped to under two hours, based on real work, and paid. Anything longer disproportionately screens out experienced candidates with families and jobs.
How long should hiring a startup engineer take?
From first contact to offer, two weeks is a competitive target. Great candidates are usually in three processes at once, and speed is a real advantage a small company has.
Should you hire contractors or employees first?
Contractors are good for bounded, well-understood work. Anything that requires accumulating product context — which is most early engineering — should be an employee.

From the podcast

Founders who lived this

Code Story episodes where founders work through the same problem in their own words.

More on future of workMore on founder lessons

Keep reading

Related guides

Startup engineering team structure that actually ships

How to structure a startup engineering team: the models that work at 5, 15 and 40 engineers, how to split teams, and the org mistakes that quietly slow delivery.

Scaling an engineering team from 5 to 50

How to scale a startup engineering team from 5 to 50 people: when to add managers, how communication breaks, what process to add at each size, and what to leave alone.

When to hire a CTO for your startup

When to hire a startup CTO: the signals that you are ready, what the role should own, realistic salary and equity ranges, and how to interview for technical leadership.

All guides